How to break Black Friday marketing rules

A few years ago I asked my (now closed) free Facebook group how they felt about Black Friday promotions.

Most of the members, mainly small business owners, had strong negative feelings about it. Not because they don't want to give their buyers a good deal, but because they already give them excellent value year-round.

And the thing is, when you're up against Amazon or the supermarkets, small indies can't budge that much on price. Their margins are tight, and they have mouths to feed.

Why do so many small businesses dread Black Friday?

Many of them echoed my own feelings, which is that Black Friday sums up so much I dislike about business. Marketing that fuels excess consumption and thrives on scarcity. Campaigns that squeeze small retailers. Messages designed to make shoppers panic-spend money (which they sometimes don't have) under a cloud of FOMO.

A disclaimer: I've bought things in Black Friday sales before and may well do so again this year. It's a chance for people to pick up a bargain, especially when money is tight, and I'm not judging anyone who shops on Black Friday. I do think it's better for everyone when we make conscious purchases and the value exchange is fair. But it's your money, and how you spend it is up to you.

The problem is that Black Friday is prime time for unethical marketing practices to be rolled out en masse. And small businesses and independents end up feeling they have no choice but to follow suit.

What choices do small businesses actually have on Black Friday?

Newsflash: you have lots of choices. You can:

  • Do nothing. Let the day (or month, as it now seems to be) pass by with no comment or action.

  • Do nothing and explain why. It's a great opportunity to let your audience get to know you and what you stand for.

  • Do the exact opposite of a traditional Black Friday campaign, like these two brands.

What can small businesses learn from Patagonia's "Don't buy this jacket"?

Patagonia says it's "in business to save our home planet". This isn't just a nice statement. It runs through everything they do.

They openly recognise that new clothes are bad for the environment, and they don't shy away from it (unlike others in the industry notorious for greenwashing). Instead of pushing you to buy new, they make it easy to get your Patagonia gear repaired, trade it in, or buy it second hand.

Their iconic 2011 Black Friday campaign saw them take out a full-page ad in the New York Times, asking people not to buy their stuff.

patagonia.png

The instruction "Don't buy this jacket" came with a stark breakdown of what it cost the planet to make (including 135 litres of water and 20lbs of CO2). In their words, it had "an environmental cost higher than its price".

Then the gut-punch call to action: "Don't buy what you don't need. Think twice before you buy anything."

I'm not saying you should go around telling people not to buy your stuff. But you can take inspiration from how Patagonia puts its purpose into action.

Notice that their purpose statement includes two key words: "in business". They don't just exist to save the planet. They exist to do it as a business, and that campaign was good for business. In the 12 months to April 2012, Patagonia's sales rose by more than 30% to around $540 million, and its profits had tripled since 2008.

They've gone much further since. They still don't run Black Friday sales on their own website. And in 2022 founder Yvon Chouinard gave the company away, restructuring it so that its profits go towards tackling the climate crisis. Earth, as they put it, is now their only shareholder.

Suddenly, having a clear purpose is more than a nice-to-have. It's central to the bottom line.

Read more about the Patagonia campaign.

What happened to Deciem's Black Friday blackout?

deciem.jpg

Deciem, the company behind The Ordinary, calls itself "the abnormal beauty company", and it lives by that tagline.

Back in 2019 it closed its stores and website on Black Friday for "a moment of nothingness". Instead, it offered 23% off everything for the whole of November, so people could shop slowly and choose their skincare based on education rather than impulse. It started life as KNOWvember and was later renamed Slowvember. In 2025 it ran from 1 November to 7 December, with the website and stores closed for transactions on Black Friday itself.

This year, Deciem has gone a step further. Slowvember isn't happening in November 2026 at all. The brand has moved its annual 23% off to April, its birthday month. Rather than reacting to a noisy retail calendar, it's created a moment that belongs to it alone.

That's the bit I love. Deciem went from opposing Black Friday to simply not playing. Their discount now marks something that matters to them, rather than a date someone else chose.

Isn't Black Friday urgency just how marketing works?

At the start of this post I said Black Friday thrives on scarcity and FOMO. The countdown clocks, the "only three left", the sale that ends at midnight (and then somehow carries on into Cyber Monday). For years these have been treated as the rules of the game, and small businesses have felt they had to play along.

Here's the twist: some of those rules now break the law.

Since April 2025, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has been able to fine businesses directly for breaking consumer protection law, up to 10% of their global turnover. Fake urgency is high on its list. The High Court has backed its finding that Emma Sleep's countdown clocks and urgency claims were illegal. And last month Wayfair was fined £4.8 million after the CMA found its 24-hour “Flash Deals” (complete with countdown timers) were often still available at the same price once the clock ran out.

So the tactics that always felt grubby now carry real risk as well. If your deadline is genuine, say so. If it isn't, don't fake it. (This isn't legal advice, but the CMA's guidance is worth a read before you plan any promotion.)

Why break the marketing rules at all?

Rules are often just old habits that hide opportunities. The Black Friday rulebook says slash your prices, shout loudly and hurry people along.

Patagonia and Deciem ignored it. One told people not to buy its jacket. The other closed its tills for the day, and has now dropped the date altogether. Neither lost out by refusing to play along.

Breaking the rules doesn't need a full-page ad in the New York Times. It might be an email to your list explaining why you're not having a sale. It might be a thank-you to your regulars, on a day of your own choosing.

Find your own way, be true to what you're bringing to the world, and live your purpose courageously.

Quick answers

When is Black Friday 2026? Friday 27 November 2026, though many retailers start their promotions weeks earlier.

Do small businesses have to take part in Black Friday? No. You can ignore it, explain why you're not taking part, or run something that reflects your values instead.

What was Patagonia's "Don't buy this jacket" campaign? A full-page New York Times ad on Black Friday 2011 asking people not to buy its fleece jacket, setting out the jacket's environmental cost. Patagonia's sales rose by more than 30% in the following year.

Is Deciem running Slowvember in 2026? No. Deciem has moved its annual 23% discount from November to April, its birthday month.

Are countdown timers illegal in the UK? Not in themselves. Misleading urgency is the problem. Fake countdown timers and false scarcity claims can break consumer law, and the CMA can fine businesses directly for them.


Next
Next

From Marketing Overwhelm to Marketing Joy: A Small Business Owner's Guide